Desktop Environments, Window Managers and the X Window System

NELUG meeting 15/3/2000
Horst Kausch
v0.1 2000-03-15

Overview

The desktop/graphical user interface experienced by the user consists of several layers.

Application
Window Manager compound

architecture

X-lib X-tended Graphical Environment
X Window System

X Window system

  • client/server architecture
  • the server delivers input events to clients and displays the output
  • the client is the application calling on the server to do the input/output processing
  • network transparent
  • X-lib library provides low-level manipulation of graphics

Window Managers

  • provides window management functions:
    • focus – which client gets input events
    • create/destroy windows
    • move windows
    • resize windows
    • stacking – raise/lower windows
  • provides window decorations as visual clues of window status and functions:
    • title bar
    • borders
    • buttons for window operations
    • window menu
    • highlighting of window with focus

Widget Sets

  • toolkits implementing the abstract objects of the user interface:
    • check buttons
    • radio buttons
    • text entry fields
    • scroll bars
    • scroll lists
    • tabbed dialogs
  • provides look and feel of the user interface (X-tended Graphical Environment)

Desktop Environment

  • panel for starting programs, displaying task list, monitors, etc.
  • desktop – object can be dragged onto desktop for quick access
  • consistent look and feel
  • standardized menu and toolbars, keybindings, color-schemes, etc.
  • internationalization
  • centralized consisted dialog driven desktop configuration
  • themeable
  • integrated help system
  • complete network transparency
  • component architecture
  • object oriented inter-program communications mechanism through CORBA or DCOM
  • Document Object Model (DOM) using XML file formats
  • suite of applications

Only KDE and Gnome (will) implement all of these features.

Advanced Feature Comparison

KDE Gnome MS Win9x
themable yes yes yes
component model KOM/OpenParts bonobo COM/ActiveX
file manager + browser Kfm (1.1)
Konqueror (2.0)
Gmc (1.0)
Nautilus (2.0)
InternetExplorer
word processor KWord abiword MS Word
spreadsheet KSpread Gnumeric MS Excel
image manipulation KIllustrator The Gimp Photoshop
personal finance — Gnucash Quicken

Typical configurations

desktop window manager widget set
plain twm Athena (libXaw)
AnotherLevel fvwm2 Athena,…
CDE mwm motif
KDE kwm Qt
Gnome enlightenment gdk/gtk

Screenshots

Plain X desktop with only an xterm and no window manager

Plain X desktop with only an xterm and no window manager


Plain X desktop with twm managing an xterm

Plain X desktop with twm managing an xterm


AnotherLevel desktop (RedHat 5.* default)

AnotherLevel desktop (RedHat 5.* default)


KDE-1.1 desktop

KDE-1.1 desktop


Gnome 1.0 desktop

Gnome 1.0 desktop

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Time limit is exhausted. Please reload the CAPTCHA.